MOREMARRONE LLC Obtains Long-Awaited Victory for Hourly Wage Workers as U.S. Supreme Court Denies Certiorari in “Important” Case, E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Co. v. Smiley

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) rejects DuPont’s appeal of Third Circuit Court of Appeals decision which unanimously reversed a District Court’s decision that would have let DuPont off the hook for wages in a collective/class action made up of workers who had been denied their overtime pay for “donning and doffing” uniforms and safety equipment, and for performing pre-shift and post-shift work.

Dupont v Smiley FLSA MOREMARRONE Decision 2018-06-28 time card

PHILADELPHIA, PA – June 28, 2018: SCOTUS considered for more than a year whether to take the case on appeal or let the Third Circuit’s ruling stand. The Third Circuit held that the District Court incorrectly concluded that the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) allowed DuPont to avoid paying overtime by taking a “credit” for break-time pay the employer had already paid, and using it to offset the employer’s overtime obligations under the FLSA for off-the-clock work. In its unanimous opinion the Third Circuit, agreeing with attorney Thomas More Marrone’s argument, explained “Here, permitting DuPont to use pay given for straight time—and included in the regular rate of pay—as an offset against overtime pay is precisely the type of ‘creative bookkeeping’ … the FLSA sought to eradicate.”

E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Co. Petitioned SCOTUS to take the case for further review on appeal, raising several issues. The hourly workers’ Counsel of Record before the Supreme Court was Thomas More Marrone of MOREMARRONE LLC, who wrote the Brief in Opposition to DuPont’s Petition. Marrone argued that:

  • DuPont waived its new lead argument by not presenting it to the District Court or to the Third Circuit Panel that decided the case,
  • The Third Circuit decision was not in conflict with Supreme Court precedent.
  • There was no true conflict of Circuits involving the question, so SCOTUS review was not necessary.
  • Even without relying upon the Department of Labor’s interpretation, the Third Circuit’s decision would have been the same, because it was independently based on the FLSA (Fair Labor Standards Act) and Third circuit precedent. Appeal to the Supreme Court would not have changed the result.

SCOTUS agreed with Marrone and denied DuPont’s Petition over the Statement of Justice Gorsuch (with whom Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Thomas joined) who would have accepted the case to consider the “important question” of deference to agency interpretations of Federal Statutes.

The case will now go back to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania for further proceedings. The practical result based on this decision is that the workers have a won their case, and yields a major win for the DuPont hourly workers. The question now to be determined is the calculation of damages and how the workers will be compensated after years of waiting during this herculean fight.

Upon learning of the decision, Thomas More Marrone commented: “This is a welcome and long-awaited victory for hourly workers, and the Third Circuit decision, which the Supreme Court let stand, is a rebuke of corporate wage theft through creative bookkeeping and corporate legal maneuvers. The named plaintiffs in this case deserve special credit for their tenacity, especially Bobbi-Jo Smiley. Her perseverance demonstrates that a strong woman from a small Pennsylvania town can take on a corporate giant and win — she is an inspiration to all, not just women and hourly workers.”

This case filed is E.I. DuPont de Nemours and Co. v. Smiley (Docket No. 16-1189), the petition for certiorari was denied on June 28, 2018 in the following Order:  https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-1189_6jf6.pdf.

Thomas More Marrone’s winning Brief may be accessed online at moremarrone.com.

Co-counsel with lawyer Thomas More Marrone of MOREMARRONE LLC is Patricia Pierce of Greenblatt, Pierce, Funt & Flores.

About Attorney Thomas More Marrone and MOREMARRONE LLC

MOREMARRONE LLC has handled cases producing some of the largest verdicts and settlements in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. The firm represents plaintiffs in significant personal injury, class action, and other complex civil litigation. After a recent 11-month stretch that included two class action jury trials resulting in a settlement and verdict amounting to well over $15 million in addition to several substantial personal injury recoveries, successful business and employment negotiations, and hundreds of satisfied clients, Tom Marrone established his multifaceted firm, MOREMARRONE LLC.

Licensed to practice in the State and Federal courts of Pennsylvania, New York, and New Jersey, Tom Marrone has extensive experience and proven success handling difficult, complex cases, especially class actions and collective actions, cases involving personal injury, employment, wage and hour claims, insurance matters, product liability, consumer protection, consumer fraud, deceptive practices, legal malpractice, and wrongful use of civil proceedings.

Individual and corporate clients also engage MOREMARRONE LLC for advisory services, including legal matters, crisis prevention, and crisis management. A veteran class action trial lawyer, Tom Marrone also offers consultations with other attorneys and law firms related to class action and complex litigation theory development, implementation, and trial strategy.

of escort çukurova escort kozan escort seyhan escort yüreğir escort adana mutlu son masaj besni escort kahta escort gölbaşı escort adıyaman mutlu son masaj bolvadin escort dinar escort sandıklı escort emirdağ escort afyon mutlu son masaj diyadin escort doğubayazıt escort patnos escort ağrı mutlu son masaj ortaköy escort aksaray mutlu son masaj merzifon escort suluova escort taşova escort amasya mutlu son masaj çankaya escort keçiören escort yenimahalle escort mamak escort etimesgut escort sincan escort altındağ escort pursaklar escort gölbaşı escort polatlı escort çubuk escort kahramankazan escort beypazari escort ankara mutlu son masaj alanya escort manavgat escort serik escort antalya mutlu son masaj şehitkamil escort nizip escort ıslahiye escort antep mutlu son masaj ardahan mutlu son masaj artvin mutlu son masaj hopa escort borçka escort aydın mutlu son masaj efeler escort nazilli escort kuşadası escort söke escort didim escort incirliova escort çine escort germencik escort balıkesir mutlu son masaj karesi escort altıeylül escort edremit escort bandırma escort gönen escort ayvalık escort burhaniye escort bigadiç escort susurluk escort bartın mutlu son masaj batman mutlu son masaj kozluk escort sason escort beşiri escort bayburt mutlu son masaj bilecik mutlu son masaj bozuyuk escort bingöl mutlu son masaj solhan escort genç escort karlıova escort bitlis mutlu son masaj tatvan escort güroaymak escort ahlat escort bolu mutlu son masaj gerede escort burdur mutlu son masaj bucak escort bursa mutlu son masaj osmangazi escort yıldırım escort nilüfer escort inegöl escort gemlik escort mudanya escort mustafakemalpaşa escort gürsu escort karacabey escort orhangazi escort kestel escort iznik escort çanakkale mutlu son masaj biga escort can escort gelibolu escort ayvacık escort çankırı mutlu son masaj çerkes escort çorum mutlu son masaj sungurlu escort osmancık escort alaca escort iskilip escort denizli mutlu son masaj pamukkale escort merkezefendi escort çivril escort acıpayam escort tavas escort diyarbakır mutlu son masaj kayapınar escort bağlar escort yenişehir escort ergani escort bismil escort sur escort silvan escort çermik escort dicle escort düzce mutlu son masaj akçakoca escort kaynaşlı escort edirne mutlu son masaj keşan escort uzunköprü escort ipsala escort elazığ mutlu son masaj kovancılar escort karakoçan escort erzincan mutlu son masaj erzurum mutlu son masaj yakutiye escort palandöken escort aziziye escort horasan escort oltu escort pasinler escort odunpazarı escort tepebaşı escort eskişehir mutlu son masaj bulancak escort espiye escort tirebolu escort görele escort giresun mutlu son masaj gümüşhane mutlu son masaj kelkit escort hakkari mutlu son masaj yüksekova escort şemdinli escort hatay mutlu son masaj antakya escort iskenderun escort defne escort dörtyol escort samandağ escort kırıkhan escort reyhanlı escort arsuz escort altınözü escort hassa escort payas escort erzin escort yayladağı escort ığdır mutlu son masaj yalvaç escort eğirdir escort sarkıkaraağaç escort ısparta mutlu son masaj istanbul mutlu son masaj izmir mutlu son masaj buca escort karabağlar escort bornova escort karşıyaka escort konak escort bayraklı escort çiğli escort torbalı escort menemen escort gaziemir escort ödemiş escort kemalpaşa escort bergama escort menderes escort aliağa escort tire escort balçova escort urla escort narlıdere escort seferihisar escort çeşme escort dikili escort güzelbahçe escort karabük mutlu son masaj safranbolu escort karaman mutlu son masaj ermenek escort kağızman escort kars mutlu son masaj sarıkamış escort tosya escort taşköprü escort cide escort kastamonu mutlu son masaj melikgazi escort kocasinan escort talas escort develi escort yahyalı escort bünyan escort kayseri mutlu son masaj kıbrıs mutlu son masaj lefkoşa escort girne escort kilis mutlu son masaj yahşihan escort kırıkkale mutlu son masaj keskin escort kırklareli mutlu son masaj lüleburgaz escort babaeski escort vize escort kaman escort kırşehir mutlu son masaj gebze escort izmit escort darıca escort körfez escort gölcük escort çayırova escort kocaeli mutlu son masaj derince escort kartepe escort başiskele escort karamürsel escort kandıra escort dilovası escort selçuklu escort karatay escort meram escort ereğli escort akşehir escort beyşehir escort cumra escort seydişehir escort ılgın escort kulu escort cihanbeyli escort karapınar escort konya mutlu son masaj tavşanlı escort simav escort gediz escort kütahya mutlu son masaj malatya mutlu son masaj yeşilyurt escort gazi escort doğanşehir escort yunusemre escort akhisar escort turgutlu escort şehzadeler escort salihli escort soma escort akhisar escort manisa mutlu son masaj onikişubat escort dulkadiroğlu escort elbistan escort afşin escort maraş mutlu son masaj kızıltepe escort mardin mutlu son masaj midyat escort artuklu escort nusaybin escort derik escort yenişehir escort toroslar escort tarsus escort mersin mutlu son masaj akdeniz escort mezitli escort erdemli escort silifke escort anamur escort mut escort bodrum escort fethiye escort milas escort menteşe escort marmaris escort muğla mutlu son masaj seydikemer escort bulanık escort malazgirt escort muş mutlu son masaj avanos escort nevşehir mutlu son masaj ürgüp escort bor escort niğde mutlu son masaj altınordu escort fatsa escort ordu mutlu son masaj perşembe escort ünye escort< düziçi escort kadirli escort osmaniye mutlu son masaj ardeşen escort çayeli escort rize mutlu son masaj adapazarı escort sakarya mutlu son masaj serdivan escort akyazı escort erenler escort hendek escort karasu escort atakum escort ilkadım escort samsun mutlu son masaj bafra escort çarşamba escort canik escort vezirköprü escort terme escort siirt mutlu son masaj sinop mutlu son masaj cizre escort silopi escort şırnak mutlu son masaj sivas mutlu son masaj sarkışla escort çerkezköy escort çorlu escort ergene escort kapaklı escort tekirdağ mutlu son masaj süleymanpaşa escort erbaa escort niksar escort tokat mutlu son masaj turhal escort zile escort akçaabat escort of escort ortahisar escort trabzon mutlu son masaj pertek escort tunceli mutlu son masaj haliliye escort eyyübiye escort siverek escort urfa mutlu son masaj karaköprü escort viranşehir escort akçakale escort suruç escort birecik escort harran escort banaz escort uşak mutlu son masaj erciş escort tuşba escort edremit escort özalp escort çaldıran escort van mutlu son masaj çiftlikköy escort çınarcık escort yalova mutlu son masaj akdağmadeni escort sorgun escort yozgat mutlu son masaj yerköy escort boğazlıyan escort çaycuma escort devrek escort ereğli escort kozlu escort zonguldak mutlu son masaj